Home Depot Competitors Analysis: 6 of Its Biggest Competitors

Home Depot is the biggest retail home improvement warehouse chain in North America. It operates 2312 big-box format stores across the United States, Mexico, and Canada and boasts over 500,000 employees, yet it still has some competitors to contend with.

Home Depot Competitors at a Glance

1. Lowe’s
2. Ace Hardware
3. Menards
4. Home Hardware
5. Amazon
6. True Value

The company was founded in 1978 in Atlanta, Georgia, by Bernie Marcus, Arthur Blank, and Pat Farrah. Unlike traditional retail stores that carry other items in addition to their primary product offering, The Home Depot stores specialize only in home improvement products. Built on a foundation of service, product selection, and competitive prices, the Home Depot mission statement reflects the company’s core values of building a 100+ billion-dollar business. 

In the 2020 financial year, it generated total revenues of $110.225 billion with a net income of USD 11.242 billion. Annual revenue in 2022 increased a whopping 14.42% from 2021 for a total of 151.157 billion, which proves that The Home Depot has dominated the home renovation space and continues to grow, despite competitor growth. 

It currently has a market cap of over $331.32 billion and trades at a price-earnings multiple of 24.20 as of August 13th, 2021 (when this article was first written). Today,  in early 2023, the market cap for Home Depot is 324.051 billion, which does reflect some decline, and with the larger macro picture in the economy, this is not a surprise. While Home Depot shares have seen some dips, they have increased in value by almost 70% in the past five years.

With strong financials, The Home Depot is clearly a formidable competitor in the home improvement market with substantial competitive advantages and has seen lasting success despite a current market dip in the past year. Only time will tell on the future growth of Home Depot, but with strong leadership at the helm, competitive advantages, and a focus on global expansion, Home Depot is still one of the top home renovation companies out there.

Home Depot’s Business Strategy

Home Depot’s business strategy focuses on large-scale customer acquisition through saturation marketing and an everyday low-price pricing strategy. Its big-box stores allow it to stock a wide range of home improvement products and provide value-for-money prices on items, including those that no other retailer stocks at all.

Its business model is to maximize the number of customers who come into a Home Depot store by focusing on volume instead of market share. This encourages consumer loyalty through discounts and free services (such as delivering heavy-duty appliances) and offering quality goods at reasonable prices.

It achieves these goals primarily through its centralized purchasing practices, which drive down costs across its entire product line, efficient management processes, excellent supplier relationships, and very effective distribution systems. The History of Home Depot as a company has largely been a reflection of its leadership teams with a strong focus on customer service at its core and it’s working! To learn more, you can check out our full Home Depot Business History article, which delves into the beginnings of this company much more. 

One of its main focuses is on market development. Its expansion into Canada and Mexico has allowed it to increase its customer base. Using its core competencies in buying and logistics, it can provide products at low prices and excellent customer service. Not to forget that it’s also developing a solid footprint in the online channel, which will further enhance its effectiveness in reaching potential customers.

Moreover, the acquisition of other retailers such as H.D. Supply Holdings, Inc., on November 16th, 2020, for a thrilling $8 billion has created even more opportunities for more extensive geographic coverage and customer reach. Its online channel will also provide Home Depot with a strong foundation to expand into other markets such as Australia, Eastern Europe, China, India, and many more.

The Home Depot’s SWOT Analysis

If you want to learn more about The Home Depot, you can check out our Home Depot SWOT analysis, which gives you a more in-depth look it its business strengths and weaknesses, but here’s an overview for you as well. 

1. Strengths

Strong Regional Footprint: The Home Depot has a significant presence throughout the United States, Mexico, and Canada, gaining geographical diversification benefits that provide much-needed protection from regional economic downturns. Although the attempt into the Chinese market failed, it still has plans to penetrate other Asian and European markets.

World-Class Logistics System: Their supply chain management processes are excellent, providing cost advantages on a great range of quality products. Also, the experience and expertise they have in their logistics network offer them the much-needed capability to manage risks associated with operational disruptions, thus enabling greater flexibility.

Robust Customer Service: Home Depot provides customers and employees with exceptional value and world-class customer service. This leads to increased customer satisfaction, loyalty, and profitability for The Home Depot.

Excellent Financial Statements: Home Depot has exceptional financial strength with a current ratio of 1.11. This means that when it comes to paying its current obligations (such as debts) in the short term, it can cover them 1.11 times over with creditors’ capital and funds already on hand. Moreover, these figures are backed by an outstanding net income of $12.866 billion during fiscal 2021 and low long-term debt, totaling $35.822 billion as of April 30th, 2021.

Strong Brand Recognition: Their brand is renowned as one of the most trusted and forefront of innovation in home improvement. This leads to increased customer spending by brand loyalty.

Weaknesses

Limited international presence: Home Depot’s main focus is on the North American market, while it has attempted to penetrate other markets with mixed success. Though the current expansion of its online channel allows for global reach, this will take some time before establishing itself in a new market and scaling up operations.

Strict focus on its core competencies: The Home Depot will remain focused on its niche home improvement market; thus, it lacks diversification. This would increase risk, as the company cannot quickly shift resources and assets to different areas that may need attention.

Opportunities

Increasing online channel sales: With the growing trend towards e-commerce, The Home Depot must ensure that it captures a larger share of this market, or it will face stiff competition from Amazon and players such as Alibaba.com in China, who already have established business models in the country ready to be leveraged.

Diversification into businesses related to green energy: Technology tools such as solar panels are booming at present. At the same time, there is high demand for green energy, especially in the U.S. and Asia. The Home Depot can attempt to diversify into this niche market by acquiring companies with high growth potential.

Home Depot could expand in new markets: Home Depot has a significant presence in the U.S. and Canada. However, there is still potential to penetrate new markets. The Asian market is a suitable area for expansion due to increasing wealth and income levels. Furthermore, Home Depot can capitalize on this by differentiating its products through innovation, thus gaining a competitive advantage.

Threats

Increased competitive pressure: Home Depot must keep innovating its product range and offering to ensure it remains at the forefront of home improvement and homemaking. They must not allow other players to use their core competencies and resources to gain a competitive advantage at the expense of The Home Depot.

Hedging against unexpected market downturns: The home improvement market is volatile, with sales being affected by the economic cycle and product lines the following suit. It must mitigate risks associated with such events using hedging strategies to guarantee its profitability during adverse times.

Home Depot Competitor Analysis

There are many competitors in the home improvement market. Home Depot competes with Lowe’s, Ace Hardware, Menard’s, True Value, Northern Tool +Equipment, ILDC, Home Hardware, Canadian Tire Corporation, Amazon, and Alibaba.com, just to name but a few.

1. Lowe’s

Lowe’s is a U.S. retailer of home improvement and supplies, founded in 1946. It is headquartered in North Carolina and offers furniture, appliances, home improvement tools, and electronic products such as computers, software, etc. It also provides installation services along with the repair and maintenance of all the goods mentioned above.

Lowe’s operates 2197 stores in North America and has about 340,000 employees. It controls about 12 percent of the home improvement market share compared to Home Depot’s 17 percent. This makes it the second-largest competitor to Home Depot, with a presence in the U.S. and Canada. Both retailers target the same market with similar offerings.

Lowe’s market share is primarily driven by its sales promotions and coupons, as well as a broad range of product categories, both online and offline.
Lowe’s recorded a 25.9 percent increase in consolidated sales in the first quarter of 2021. In the U.S., consolidated sales increased by 24.4 percent to $16.3 billion.

Lowe’s has a total asset base of $46.735 billion, with over 2197 stores in operation in 2021.
Lowe’s is expanding its acquisitions strategy to leverage growth opportunities and enter new markets. The acquisition of Rona Inc. in Canada is expected to increase its market share in that country. Also, involvement in the e-commerce segment will have a significant impact on its sales with an increased focus on special offers and discounts for online shoppers.

2. Ace Hardware

Ace Hardware is an American retailer of home improvement and supplies. Headquartered in Illinois, it operates more than 5000 stores in 60 countries. The company was founded in 1924 and has plans to employ over 30,000 associates worldwide by the end of 2021.
It leverages its competitive strengths, such as product variety across multiple categories and distribution channels, to provide value-added services such as installation/repair for customers.

It also provides a line of proprietary branded products that help it stand out from competitors.
Moreover, it ranks 1st in the customer satisfaction index in the home improvement sector as per a study by J.D. Power. Ace Hardware offers extended hours of operation and convenient locations that provide an all-inclusive shopping experience to its customers.

It also provides a network of service centers to repair and replace products in the case of damage or malfunction.
Ace Hardware has made significant acquisitions to strengthen its supply chain and presence across international markets. It is paying close attention to product diversification, online presence, and new stores in strategic locations to expand its market share.

3. Menards

Menards is a chain of home improvement and supplies retail stores based in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. It employs about 45000 people in its 335 outlets throughout the U.S., with local branches and stores in 23 countries. The company was founded in 1960 as a family-owned business and has flourished into one of the largest hardware chains in North America.

Menards takes pride in its ability to provide technical expertise and quality products at affordable prices. It has aligned itself with a strong network of suppliers that help it maintain an efficient supply chain. The company leverages its competitive strengths, such as wider product categories and broader store locations, to offer a unique shopping experience for customers.

It’s known for providing high-quality products with exceptional value at low costs through differentiation strategies such as home decorator services, special discounts, online shopping, etc. In addition to this, the retailer provides exceptional customer service by offering extended opening hours and convenient locations where consumers can shop from within their local area without driving far away from home.

In 2020, Menards recorded a revenue of $10.7 billion, a 7 percent increase over the previous year. The company has planned a large number of product categories and new stores to enhance sales in 2021. In 2020, it ranked 31st in the Forbes list as America’s largest private company.

4. Home Hardware

Home Hardware is a Canadian retailer of home improvement and hardware products with 2,658 employees across 138 stores. Home Hardware was founded in 1964 by Walter Hachborn as a family business located in St. Jacobs, Ontario.

It has since grown into one of the largest chains of hardware retailers in North America. The store offers a wide selection of goods, including lumber & building materials; indoor & outdoor power tools; garden supplies & equipment; plumbing & heating; generators & lighting; air conditioning & water treatment; kitchen cabinetry & appliances; electrical accessories, and more.

It leverages its competitive strength, such as operational excellence and e-commerce expertise, to provide an excellent shopping experience for customers. Its unparalleled range of products committed technical support, and superior customer service allows it to serve its extensive client base efficiently. In 2022, the store aims at strengthening its supply chain capabilities across all of its locations while increasing product diversity through a variety of new retail outlets.

5. Amazon

This analysis would be incomplete without including the giant of e-commerce, Amazon. The online retailer has been rapidly expanding its offerings and acquiring new companies to provide a wider spectrum of products for customers.

Amazon offers the lowest prices among all competitors due to its efficient supply chain capabilities and acquisitive nature to expand into new product categories. In addition to this, Amazon leverages affiliate marketing techniques through third-party sellers on the platform to gain incremental revenue from transactions made on its platform.

With a global presence in 20 countries, Amazon strengthens its supply chain capabilities by setting up more warehouses across different regions to improve delivery times and reduce shipping costs. It plans on establishing new distribution centers for retail and wholesale purposes in strategic locations across the world to serve over 4.6 billion international online populations.

In the home improvement space, Amazon has been playing catch up with Home Depot and Lowe’s in recent years due to the higher costs of its operations and increasing competition from e-commerce players. However, it continues to expand aggressively, leveraging the huge growth potential in the sector, especially considering its home improvement sector is still a small fraction of its overall retail sales.

6. True Value

The True Value Company is another direct, major competitor in the home improvement space, but unlike Home Depot, True Value prides itself on being locally owned, operated, and delivering on service since its inception in 1912 when John Cotter founded his first local hardware store. True Value prides itself on its global expansion, yet keeping with that same local business feel in each of its 4500 stores worldwide. Both True Value and Home Depot offer a wide selection of tools, home decor, appliances, lawn care, and home decorating and improvement products.

The Management Team at True Value is led by Chris Kempa, who joined the True Value team in 2019 and brings over 25 years of retail experience and has executed an “integrated merchandising, sales and go-to-market strategy” to ensure True Value’s expansion and growth in the market. True Value’s CEO is relatively new to the role compared to Home Depot, who has had Ted Decker, Chair, President and CEO at the helm since 2000, focusing on global expansion, the global supply chain, merchandise, and marketing strategies and has been a strategic leader at the company in a variety of positions. Both CEOs have strong backgrounds in the retail industry, yet Home Depot’s CEO seems to have had more time to expand and improve the company.

The company ethos at True Value has always been to support local owners, but in recent years, they have abandoned their Cooperative business model when private equity firm Acon Investments bought a 70% stake in the True Value business. This update created 500 new stores and pumped 150 million into supply-chain improvements for the company. In 2021, True Value had 1.5 billion in annual revenue, which sounds impressive until you compare it to Home Depot’s whopping 151.2 billion dollar revenue that same year. While it doesn’t look like True Value is going to take over the immense market share of Home Depot, it is still a competitor worth looking into as their continued commitments to grow, expand and support local retailers remains. 

How Home Depot Stands Out Against Its Competitors

Home Depot is one of the pioneers in the home improvement industry, and it continues to set new standards for service delivery. Unlike its competitors, Home Depot strategically separates its online channel from its brick-and-mortar stores to maintain a customer base that is loyal to both channels.
The retailer invests heavily in infrastructure in an attempt to improve customer experience across all channels.

It maximizes its existing infrastructural capabilities by strengthening supply chain reliability, operational excellence, and technological advancements to enhance customer satisfaction.

Further, Home Depot’s international expansion strategy includes leveraging its expertise and technological innovations to reposition itself as a leader in the home improvement space across different geographies. The retailer has established successful partnerships with local retailers in Mexico and Canada to gain incremental revenue from existing customers who want a broader product range.

Home Depot Competitor Analysis (FAQs)

Conclusion

Home Depot has a variety of strengths that are going to be pivotal in its continued growth. It provides superior customer service across all channels, which allows it to serve customers more efficiently than its competitors. The retailer also invests in infrastructure to create a top-notch customer experience. In addition, Home Depot’s international expansion strategy is something worth noting as the company continues to expand into new markets.

Recommended Reads:

• Home Depot SWOT Analysis
• Starbucks Mission Statement Explained
• DoorDash Competitors Analysis : 4 Strongest Competitors
• FedEx Mission Statement Explained : What is FedEx’s Philosophy?
• Bernard Arnault Bio
• YETI Competitors Analysis

• About
• Latest Posts

John Hughes

John Hughes is a seasoned expert in digital marketing strategy, business model analysis, and financial insights. Possessing a robust background in finance, his expertise extends into deciphering complex business models, conducting comprehensive SWOT analyses, and staying attuned to the latest market trends.

Latest posts by John Hughes (see all)

• Dan Bilzerian Bio - December 9, 2022
• OLA Model Explained - November 23, 2022
• Service Value Chain Explained - November 23, 2022